The short answer
Yes, when it's a policy from an insurance company licensed in your state. The FTC puts it plainly: "All companies selling health insurance must be licensed by your state insurance commissioner." You can check that yourself. In Florida, look the company up on the Office of Insurance Regulation's Company Search. The bad name comes from products that aren't insurance at all, like medical discount plans and sharing ministries, and from standalone short-term plans that are temporary by design. If you switch, keep your current coverage until the new plan's start date is in writing.
This is for people buying their own coverage, like the self-employed, people retiring before 65 and families paying full price on the Marketplace, who have heard about private health insurance and wonder whether it's real. If you earn too much for a tax credit, a private-market plan outside the ACA often costs less, if your health qualifies you. These plans aren't ACA plans, and they cover things differently. How they compare is in the private plans vs. the marketplace guide. This page is about the question that comes before that one.
Why you may not have heard of these plans
HealthCare.gov sells Marketplace plans. Private-market plans outside the ACA aren't on it, so they never come up when you shop there. Insurance companies sell them directly and through licensed agents like me. A plan you only hear about from an agent can sound like a sales pitch. That's a fair reason to check it, and the checks below don't depend on my word.
Is it real insurance?
A private-market plan is a policy issued by an insurance company. The company has to be licensed in your state, and in Florida that's the job of the Office of Insurance Regulation (OIR). The OIR tells buyers to "verify that the entity or individual offering coverage is properly licensed in Florida," and it warns that an entity working without authorization "puts consumers at significant financial risk." Other states have their own insurance department doing the same job.
A private-market plan outside the ACA is real insurance, and it isn't an ACA plan. You should hear both from whoever sells you one. Many of these plans ask health questions when you apply, and what each one covers is written in its own documents. Off-exchange ACA plans are private market too, and those are ACA plans with the ACA's rules.
What people mean by "junk insurance"
The phrase gets attached to different products. Here is what each one is.
- Medical discount plans. The FTC says they're not insurance and "not a substitute for health insurance." You pay a monthly fee for discounts from a list of providers. If that's all you have, the FTC warns, you may have to cover most or all of a medical bill yourself.
- Health care sharing ministries. Members share each other's bills. They aren't insurance either: Florida law makes them say so in writing, in a notice covered on the plan checklist. I don't offer them.
- Standalone short-term plans. These are insurance, but temporary by design. Under Florida law, the buyer has to sign a notice that the coverage "is not required to comply with certain federal market requirements for health insurance, principally those contained in the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act." The same notice says to check for limits on pre-existing conditions and benefits, and that when it ends "you might have to wait until an open enrollment period to get other health insurance coverage." I don't offer standalone short-term plans.
The test I'd put to any plan: can it drop you, or turn down your claims, because you got sick after you enrolled? If a plan asks health questions, a solid one asks them before you're covered, and its own documents say "guaranteed renewable," with the exceptions listed. The private-market plan checklist has the seven things I read in a plan's documents.
How to check the insurance company
- Find the company's name on the documents. The application or the policy names the insurance company that issues it. That's the name to search, not the plan's name.
- In Florida, search the OIR's Company Search. It gives full names, business addresses and identifying information, and you can search by company name, company type and authorized lines of business. Check that the company you found is the one on your documents, and look at its lines of business.
- Outside Florida, ask your state's insurance department. The FTC says to check with your state insurance commissioner's office.
- Check the agent separately. A licensed company and a licensed agent are two different lookups. The guide to checking an agent walks through the second one.
How to switch without a gap
The gap happens when the old plan ends before the new one starts. The order that avoids it:
- Apply while you're still covered. A private-market plan outside the ACA can start as soon as you're approved, sometimes the same day. Keep paying your current plan until then.
- Get the start date in writing, then end the old plan. HealthCare.gov's own advice on ending a Marketplace plan: "Don't end your Marketplace plan until you know for sure when your new coverage starts to avoid a gap in coverage."
- Know that the Marketplace door doesn't reopen mid-year. The same page says that once you end Marketplace coverage, "you can't re-enroll until the next Open Enrollment Period" unless you qualify for a special enrollment period. The private-market plans I place don't count as minimum essential coverage, so losing one later doesn't open a special enrollment period either. The special enrollment guide has the details.
- Leaving a job plan? Your COBRA election window is its own clock. The COBRA guide covers how it works next to a new plan.
Questions people ask
Is private health insurance a scam?
No, not when it's a policy from an insurance company licensed in your state. The FTC warns about products sold as if they were health insurance, like some medical discount plans. Check the company on your state's insurance department search, check the agent's license, and read the plan's documents before you pay.
Why don't I see private-market plans on HealthCare.gov?
HealthCare.gov sells Marketplace plans. Private-market plans outside the ACA are sold by insurance companies directly and through licensed agents, so they don't appear there.
Is a standalone short-term plan the same as a private-market plan?
No. A standalone short-term plan is temporary by design, and in Florida the buyer signs a notice that it doesn't have to follow the ACA's rules. A private-market plan built to keep you covered says "guaranteed renewable" in its documents.
Can I go back to the Marketplace if I switch?
At open enrollment, yes. Mid-year, only with a special enrollment period, and losing a plan that isn't minimum essential coverage doesn't open one. Plan the move back for open enrollment.
Want me to look at a plan you were offered?
Send me the plan's name and the company on the documents. I'll tell you what it is and what it doesn't cover.
Book a call →The bottom line
Private health insurance is real insurance when a company licensed in your state issues the policy, and you can check that yourself. Keep it apart from the products that aren't insurance, read the plan's documents, and don't end your old coverage until the new start date is in writing. Text or call if you'd like me to compare it with the Marketplace for you.
Sources
- FTC, How to spot health insurance scams
- Florida Office of Insurance Regulation, Unauthorized Entities and Company Search
- Florida Statutes, section 627.6426, short-term health insurance
- HealthCare.gov, How do I cancel my Marketplace plan?
