CAPRIO HEALTH
Home › Health Insurance 101 › Check an agent
Health Insurance 101

How to check a health insurance agent before you trust one

You don't have to take any agent's word for it, mine included. Here's how to check one yourself, what to ask on the first call, and what should make you walk away.

The short answer

Look the agent up on the state's license search. In Florida that's the Department of Financial Services Licensee Search, and you want a valid license with health in the license type. Then ask how they're paid, how many insurance companies they work with, and whether they'll show you Marketplace plans and private-market plans side by side, with what each one leaves out. Walk away from pressure to sign today, or a request for card or bank details before you've seen a plan in writing. You don't need an agent at all to buy a Marketplace plan: HealthCare.gov offers free help by phone and in person.

This is for people buying their own coverage: families, the self-employed, people retiring before 65, in Tampa Bay or anywhere else in Florida. The steps work on any agent, and that includes me. I'm an agent, so I'm not a neutral source on agents. That's why each check below runs against the state's records or the government's own pages, not against my word.

1. Check the license yourself

HealthCare.gov's definition of an agent says agents and brokers "must be licensed in their states." In Florida, the place to check is the Department of Financial Services Licensee Search. You can search by name, by Florida license number, or by NPN. Click the agent's name in the results to open the full record. Look at three things.

  • Is the license valid? The record has separate lists for valid and invalid licenses. The license should be under Valid Licenses.
  • Does it cover health? Look for "health" in the license type.
  • Any discipline? It isn't on the record yet. The department's own Licensee Search FAQ says it plans to add enforcement and disciplinary actions to each record in a future update. Until then it points to the state's Florida Agency Indexed Orders search. Pick Department of Financial Services as the agency and Insurance Agent & Agency Services as the subject, then search the agent's name.

The NPN is the agent's National Producer Number. It stays the same in every state the agent is licensed in, so it's the easiest thing to search. Ask for it. An agent who won't give it to you has told you something.

Outside Florida, use that state's insurance department lookup. Some states share a lookup run by the NAIC, the National Association of Insurance Commissioners. Others run their own. The same NPN works in both.

2. Know the free help, and that you don't need an agent

You don't need an agent to buy a Marketplace plan. HealthCare.gov's help page lists three ways to get help applying and enrolling: by phone, with an in-person assister, or with an agent or broker. You can also apply on your own.

  • The Marketplace Call Center. Free help by phone. HealthCare.gov says you can call to ask a question, start or finish an application, compare plans, or enroll.
  • Navigators and other assisters. HealthCare.gov describes in-person assisters as "people trained & certified by the Marketplace to provide free help," also called navigators, enrollment assisters or certified application counselors. Its Find Local Help tool is how you find one near you. HealthCare.gov's glossary says a Navigator's services are free, and that Navigators help with Marketplace coverage, including the eligibility and enrollment forms.

The money works differently. In states where the federal government runs the Marketplace, Florida among them, Navigators are paid through federal grants from CMS. CMS says no one can serve as a Navigator in those federally run Marketplaces without that grant funding. Agents are another matter: HealthCare.gov says they're generally paid by insurance companies when the people they help enroll in a plan they sell.

Medicare questions have their own free help. If you're turning 65 or helping a parent, Florida's SHINE program (Serving Health Insurance Needs of Elders) offers free one-on-one counseling through the Florida Department of Elder Affairs and your local Area Agency on Aging. I don't sell Medicare, so for that side, start there.

So what can an agent add? One who works with several insurance companies can compare them for you, including plans you won't find on the Marketplace, and be someone to call once you're enrolled. If an agent can't say what they add over the free help, notice that.

3. Questions to ask any agent

Ask these on the first call. None of them is rude, and a good agent answers each one plainly.

How are you paid, and does it change from plan to plan?

HealthCare.gov says agents and brokers often get commissions from insurance companies, and that "you won't pay anything additional if you enroll with an agent or broker." The follow-up question is whether the commission changes depending on which plan you pick.

A good answer: who pays them, that you pay no fee on top of your premium, and a straight yes or no on whether pay differs between plans. My own answer is on the how I'm paid page.

How many insurance companies do you work with?

HealthCare.gov draws the line this way: agents "may work for a single health insurance company," while brokers "may represent several companies," and some "may not sell plans of companies they don't represent." An agent tied to one company can only show you that company's plans. That isn't wrong, but you should know it before you compare.

A good answer: how many companies, which kinds of plans they can sell, and a plain "I can't offer that one" when it comes up.

Will you show me Marketplace plans and private-market plans, and what each one gives up?

When you buy your own coverage, there are two kinds of plans. ACA plans follow the Affordable Care Act's rules whether you buy them on the Marketplace or straight from the insurer. An off-exchange ACA plan is still an ACA plan. The premium tax credit only applies to Marketplace plans.

Private-market plans outside the ACA are a different product, and they aren't ACA plans. If your health qualifies you, one can be a good fit. Many ask health questions when you apply, and those can turn an application down.

A good answer: both kinds side by side, which kind each plan is, and what it doesn't cover. The private-market plan checklist lists what to read in the documents.

Can I see the full plan documents before I enroll?

The FTC's advice on spotting health insurance scams is to insist on a statement of benefits or a complete copy of the policy before you sign up. A quote isn't the plan. Ask for the documents that say what's covered, what isn't, and when coverage can end.

Who do I call after I enroll?

Ask who handles a denied claim, a bill that looks wrong, or a renewal notice, and whether that's them. A good answer names what they'll help with and what they won't.

Do I have to decide on this call?

You shouldn't have to. A real deadline is a different thing. Open enrollment has fixed dates, and a good agent can show you where they come from. The open enrollment guide has this year's.

4. Warning signs

  • Pressure to sign today. The FTC lists pressure to sign up quickly, or a "special deal" about to run out, as a reason to say no.
  • Vague answers about pay. If an agent won't say who pays them, or whether it changes by plan, you have your answer.
  • Card or bank details before you've seen a plan. HealthCare.gov's fraud page says you pay Marketplace premiums "directly to the plan, not anyone else," and that the Marketplace, assisters and your state will never ask for your credit card information to keep or qualify for coverage.
  • Cash, gifts or other perks. The same page warns about health insurance ads on social media that offer them, because the information you share "could be used without your consent."
  • A plan described as something it isn't. Ask the plain question: is this an ACA plan? An off-exchange ACA plan is one. A private-market plan outside the ACA isn't, and an honest agent tells you which one you're looking at and what it doesn't cover. Some products aren't insurance at all. The FTC says medical discount plans are not insurance. Florida law requires health care sharing ministries to say, in substance, that the organization "is not an insurance company." If an agent blurs those lines, keep looking.
  • Changes you didn't approve. A July 2026 GAO report on agents and brokers in the federal Marketplace found that consumer complaints of unauthorized enrollments and plan switches grew more than fourfold from 2023 through 2025. If you're on a HealthCare.gov plan, keep your own login and check your plan there after any call with an agent.

If something feels wrong, HealthCare.gov says to report it to the FTC and to contact the Marketplace Call Center.

5. How I handle each of these

Run every check above on me. Here's where to find each answer.

  • My license. My NPN is 22091157. I'm licensed in 23 states, with Florida as my resident state. The license page lists every state, each license number, and where to look it up.
  • How I'm paid. The insurance company pays my commission when you enroll in a plan through me. You don't pay me a fee, and commissions aren't the same on every plan. The how I'm paid page covers it.
  • Both sides. I compare more than one insurance company, and I compare both sides of the market for everyone. If your health qualifies you for a private-market plan outside the ACA, we look at those too. When a Marketplace plan fits you better, I'll tell you. If another option is better for you, even one I don't offer, I'll tell you that too.
  • The first call. It usually takes about 30 minutes. I ask about your situation, when you need coverage to start, and the doctors and prescriptions you want to keep. Usually I can show you quotes on that first call. Usually we set a second call to go over the options together before you choose.
  • After you enroll. I check in before open enrollment and at renewal.

If you check my license and something looks off, tell me.

Questions people ask

How do I check if an insurance agent is licensed in Florida?

Search the agent's name, Florida license number or NPN on the Florida Department of Financial Services Licensee Search, then open the record. The license should be listed under Valid Licenses, with health in the license type. Disciplinary orders aren't on that record yet. The department points to the Florida Agency Indexed Orders search for those.

Do I need a broker to buy health insurance?

No. You can apply for a Marketplace plan yourself on HealthCare.gov, get free help from the Marketplace Call Center, or find a free assister through HealthCare.gov's Find Local Help. An agent is optional. A good one compares more than one insurance company, can show you plans outside the Marketplace, and is there after you enroll.

Is it free to use a health insurance broker?

HealthCare.gov says you won't pay anything additional if you enroll with an agent or broker. They're generally paid a commission by the insurance company. The how I'm paid page explains how it works for me.

What's the difference between a Navigator and an insurance agent?

A Navigator helps you apply for and enroll in Marketplace coverage for free, and in states where the federal government runs the Marketplace, as it does in Florida, Navigators are funded by federal grants from CMS. An agent is licensed by the state and is generally paid by insurance companies. An agent may also sell plans outside the Marketplace, so ask which ones.

How can I tell if a health plan is real insurance?

Check that the seller is licensed, and get the policy or a statement of benefits in writing before you pay. The FTC says medical discount plans are not insurance, and Florida law requires health care sharing ministries to say they are not an insurance company. Then ask whether it's an ACA plan, and if it isn't, what it doesn't cover. The guide to whether private health insurance is legit walks through checking the insurance company itself.

Want to run these checks on me?

Start with my license page. Then ask me any question on this one.

See my licenses →

The bottom line

Check the license, ask how the agent is paid, and get both kinds of plans and the full documents in front of you before you choose. You can skip the agent and use the free help instead. An agent worth working with won't mind being checked. Text or call if you'd like to start with me.

Call RyanText Ryan